user interface copyright
user interface copyright
Following a non-jury trial, which began in early January 1987,a federal judge ruled on 1990-06-28 that keyboard commands andon-screen images produced by Lotus Development Corporation'spopular 1-2-3 spreadsheet are protected by copyright.Paperback Software International and subcontractorStephenson Software Ltd. who lost the case, argued that thecopyright applies only to the inner workings of the software.US District Judge Robert Keeton wrote that "The user interfaceof 1-2-3 is its most unique element and is the aspect that hasmade 1-2-3 so popular. That defendants went to such troubleto copy that element is a testament to its substantiality".Defence attorneys had argued that the Lotus commandsrepresented "instructions for a machine rather than theexpression of an idea".
Soon after this decision, on 1990-07-02, Lotus sued Borland International and the Santa Cruz Operation for producingspreadsheets (Quattro, Quattro Pro and SCO Professional)whose interfaces could be configured to look like 1-2-3's.